The tale of Vicky and Casey White (no relation) is a love story for the ages. One of them was a well-respected security guard for a small-time jail... the other was a career criminal and inmate under her charge.

We are taking a slightly more serious turn with this episode by discussing the horrible murder at Lehigh University that led to the creation of The Clery Act of 1990 (officially known as the Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Crime Statistics Act):.

Put on your creepiest Nicolas Cage smile, because we are heading to The Rock itself... Alcatraz Island!

What happens when you bring a number of bushy and bright-eyed college students to play guards and inmates for the awesome pay of $15 a day? We find out within the confines of Jordan Hall at Stanford University.

Athlete. Ladies' man. Drug pusher. Anti-hero. Operative. These are just some of the words you could use to describe Jimmy Keene, the individual recruited by the FBI to befriend (and gather incriminating evidence against) Larry Hall.

Get ready to fix bayonets and charge while letting your epic mutton chops flutter in the wind, because we are about to discuss re-enactment soldier, Mopar enthusiast, and suspected serial killer Larry Hall!

We are going way back in time for a cautionary true crime tale, y'all... one that involves an ancient king, a corrupt judge, and the ultimate "f*#$ around and find out" symbolic punishment!

As we begin part 2 of this series, we see the firsthand account provided by Tony Harris concerning Herb Baumeister's modus operandi, and how old Herb's life gets turned upside down (but not in a fresh prince sort of way).

How can one improve upon the thrift shop business model? What is the taste of human urine? These are important questions asked by Herbert the Pervert... suspected serial killer and future owner of Fox Hollow Farm.

Today we are going a bit off the rails and looking into a different flavor of cult: one that is not based on faith, but on one of the most popular video games of all time... Final Fantasy 7!

In this hilarious and different episode, we bring in a very special guest: Jenn's little sister... the rainbow agent of chaos herself... Kelly! In the first half, the librarian brings her own little fun facts and corrections to past episodes. To finish out, she educates us on the brief history of the screeching swole lord of the Pine Barrens: The Jersey Devil!

In part 2 of our story on the intelligent and evil "Monster Preacher" Gary Heidnik, we see the events that transpire in a true basement of horrors.

"It puts the lotion on its skin"... everyone knows the chilling words of fictional serial killer Jame "Buffalo Bill" Gumb; some people may even know that his modus operandi was based on the traits of real serial killers. The least known of this murderous mash-up was an intelligent, manipulative, and eccentric monster named Gary Heidnik.

This week we have a unique split episode as we recover from William Bonin's crimes. We begin with an interview with a friend, Candace, on a missing loved one and the update that we have gotten since recording. For the second half we speak to her son Eli on his first-hand bigfoot encounter which is, as we all know, one of our favorite subjects! While we’re green with envy, Eli has a unique story that will have you rethinking who Bigfoot is and why he has this special connection. Thanks to Candace and her husband Michael for their support and their trust to share their stories!

We are finally here at the end of the road, and the end sure didn't come fast enough!

After a long time period of seemingly unrelated murders, the dots were at last connected; the news media dubbed this monster the "Freeway Killer", and the story gained traction everywhere very quickly.

Welcome back to the uplifting, feel-good story of William Bonin! In the third part of this series, we see his escalation and brutality evolve during both his solo and accomplice-supported murders.

If you're anything like us, you need a bit of a break from the madness of old creepy Billy Bodin, so we're coming at you with one of Jenn's favorite haunts (BA-DUM-TISS)!

It begins with some good old satanic panic-era Dungeons & Dragons and city-wide morbid games of Clue, but the games are about to take a much darker turn.

One of the most vile and disgusting serial killers in American history is on full display as we begin the dark, dark drive down a highway system of terror and death.